Spencer's normally good with faces which is why it's so frustrating for him that he doesn't recognize the man in the photo. What that likely means, of course, is either the man hasn't been in Siren Cove and Joel is wrong about him being responsible or has been practicing so much caution that he hasn't been seen. The latter makes Spencer shiver a bit.

"He doesn't look familiar," he admits, eyes flickering between Levi and the photo. "What does that mean, that I haven't seen him? I just-- I mean, what's next?"